Those pesky cookie consent notices…

Those that know me probably know I do go off on one when it comes to annoying uses of cookies. Well, I came across two allegedly GDPR-compliant consent pages today, each of which amazed me but for diametrically opposing reasons.

The first of the two threw up a box obscuring most of the website telling me it uses cookies, that I can find out why in the privacy notice, and then saying “You are hereby requested to accept the use of these cookies”. No other options.

Ok. First off, the privacy notice had just about zero information about what cookies it set and what these were used for. Fail. Next, there is no way to consent or refuse. Fail. The only way to remove the annoying box is to accept. Fail. Oh, and by the way it had already set the cookies anyway regardless of if I accepted or not. Major fail!

The second example I came across was so different. Here, and in just three sentences at the bottom of the screen, it told me what it used, why it used them, and below this were a series of 4 tick boxes for Necessary, Preference, Statistics, and Marketing, all ticked except Marketing. I didn’t even need to read the linked privacy notice nor anything else to know that the options it was offering were the ones I would have chosen anyway. This is by far the best implementation of a cookie consent popup I have ever seen! YMMV.